CMC Eps 22 – Matthew 17:24-27 – IDENTITY




Hi.. I’m Gene Ort.. and you’re listening to the common man commentary..

So.. here we go..   The Title for this podcast is: “ IDENTITY 

This is podcast episode 22..  

We will be looking at Matthew 17:24-27

READING : When they came to Capernaum, the collectors of the two-drachma tax went up to Peter and said, “Does your teacher not pay the tax?”  He said, “Yes.” And when he came into the house, Jesus spoke to him first, saying, “What do you think, Simon? From whom do kings of the earth take toll or tax? From their sons or from others?”  And when he said, “From others,” Jesus said to him, “Then the sons are free.  However, not to give offense to them, go to the sea and cast a hook and take the first fish that comes up, and when you open its mouth you will find a shekel. Take that and give it to them for me and for yourself.”


This is the story of the Temple Tax where Jesus sends Peter off to fish for their taxes.  I most often think of this story and apply it to God’s incredible provision for us. He can make what ever we need appear when exactly we need it. This is certainly true but not the only message.


The story has two tax gathering men asking Peter if Jesus pays taxes.. they were there to collect the annual Temple Tax..  Peter says yes he does.. Inside the house, Jesus pulls Peter aside.. my guess is Peter is getting used to being “pulled aside”. Jesus asks Peter…who pays the kings taxes.. his subjects or his children ? Peter answers.. “his subjects”. 


Ding Ding Ding..  Peter gets it right. So Jesus establishes the point again.. “Then the children get off free.. right ?” But to be nice.. and cooperative..  we will pay the tax..


Now Jesus sends him fishing… for a coin.   That should either make you laugh or scratch your head. That last thought Jesus plants in Peter’s mind is.. “the children get off free “.. 


now, fast forward.. he is setting by the lake or maybe more likely in a boat.. fishing… thinking..  my guess is pondering..  Peter was completely aware of his own culture and religion. A Jew. The Jewish law was what he had been taught from birth. A strong dose of religion. What Jesus was introducing to him was revolutionary. Peter knew exactly how to be a “subject of the King”.. that was well known. Obey the laws ! or maybe better put.. pay the tax !.. What was new to him was the idea of being “A Child of the King”.


This may be the first time Peter has been faced with this truth. Jesus is forcing the hand.  Forcing Peter to recognize his position as a child of God. This is a very powerful realization. 


The law makes subjects out of all of us. Love makes children… 


by birth or by adoption. Jesus is making this distinction.  It’s important.


Imagine Peter.. pondering this new thought… out fishing on the lake.



As a child and young man I spent a lot of time fishing. I was born into a family of fishermen. I have sat in boats and on docks for hours on end. My favorite type was steelhead fishing.  I would wade out into the water about waist deep and feel the power of the current pressing against me. Then the thrill of a 20 lb Steelhead or Salmon strike. The adrenaline flows and your heart pumps. Even after decades have past, I can still remember some of those strikes just like it was yesterday.

It’s easy for me to see myself fishing like Peter. In solitude. Waiting. Thinking. “I am a child of the king”..?   He doesn’t feel like the child of the king … His identity is … what ?


Hot head.. fisherman.. loud mouth.. under achiever.. uneducated..brawler..  



I hear and read discussions all the time about identity. Where you find it… how you lose it… your real one.. your fake one.. Your shadow self. 


Every season of life has an impact on your identity. The question of identity, who am I,  is central to how we live our life. Jesus knew that was true then just as it’s true now.


I have struggled with identity issues most of my life. Ranging from crippling insecurity and poor self image to the mask of narcissistic over achieving, self important approval addict. I brought all of my identity issues with me when I entered the Christian community. They did not just fall off the day I accepted Christ.  And just like Peter, Jesus is pointing me toward a new realization: “I am a Child of The King”.


And there Peter sets.. fishing… my guess is he had a good long time to think about this before the moment… the strike!  Even if you been fishing your whole life, its still exciting.. I know many grown men who spend countless amounts of time and money to get that little thrill.  It’s a rush.. an adrenaline rush.. bam!  Fish on !


Jesus knows a fact or two about us humans. We tend to remember things better when the adrenaline is flowing. This is not a fishing trip that Peter will ever forget.  With heart pumping, he remembers Jesus instructions for the first fish he catches ” Open it’s mouth and you will find a coin, take it and give it to the tax men. It will be enough for both of us.”


As Peter handed the coin to the tax men, he had to be moved by the power of this emerging message. It changes everything. He was beginning to see himself as a child of the king. In contrast to being the “subjects of the king “ that he was giving the coin too.


Jesus knew it would take more than a mere proclamation, “we are children of the king”  to print this seed of truth in Peter’s heart. We are no different. The obstacles that shield this truth and the power that comes from embracing it are many. I don’t think coming to the full realization of this truth is doable on our own steam. We need the same kind of personal miracle, a word from God that Peter had. 


That’s the picture of Jesus pulling Peter aside. We are dependent on Jesus for this. You cannot muster this up on your own. The picture is you and Jesus, together. Alone. You asking the question: Jesus, who am I ?  And listening for His answer. He will tell you who you are. You are a Child of the King ! Loved in a perfect way, right now, as you are. He is not waiting for you to be perfect to love you.  When you hear it for yourself, in your heart, you will never forget it. You will never be the same.


Well thats enough to think about for now..


Until next time ..  I am Gene Ort and Thank you for listening to the common man commentary. 


I’D LIKE TO LEAVE YOU WITH This “ blessing :


Love God. Love Yourself. Love the next person He puts in front of you.